Question:
Car Insurance question: Hitting a deer is 'collision' .. hitting a tree is 'other than collision'?
anonymous
2008-12-04 17:37:21 UTC
So, on a Personal Auto Policy (PAP) if you hit a tree it's considered a 'Collision.' .. but if you hit a deer, it's considered 'Other Than Collision.'

... WHY?

Is it because trees don't move and deers do?
Eleven answers:
A. Steward
2008-12-04 18:15:06 UTC
You can't be held at fault for an animal hitting your car, thus it is comprehensive or "other than collision". Unless the tree is growing legs and walking in your path, you are going to be at fault there. It is definitely collision.



As a side note, this is almost always to the benefit of the insured. Often they will have a lower comprehensive deductible or will carry comp but not collision.
?
2016-09-01 15:16:45 UTC
I might suggest that you try this website where you can compare quotes from the best companies: http://insure-cheap.info/index.html?src=2YAikdAai82nb



RE :Car Insurance question: Hitting a deer is 'collision' .. hitting a tree is 'other than collision'?

So, on a Personal Auto Policy (PAP) if you hit a tree it's considered a 'Collision.' .. but if you hit a deer, it's considered 'Other Than Collision.'



... WHY?



Is it because trees don't move and deers do?

Update: MSAD - you are very observant! =]

I did word it wrong in the actual question, but I wrote it properly in the 'extended' part of the question.



'Collision' -- hitting a tree.

'Other than Collision' -- hitting a deer.



I understand the difference between the two, I just worded it wrong on the top part of the question.

I was just curious as to why one is 'other than collision' when you colided with an object in both cases =]

Thank you for clearing that up.



I am going to take a State Exam here pretty quick and I have a few random questions I'm still not piecing together.



Home Owners Insurance is driving me up the wall! lol.

All the policies and coverages .. property coverages .. not to mention I'm just now getting to the 'Business Auto' policies and 'Commercial Auto' policies .. on top of all the other forms I've already learned.



I'll probably be in this Insurance section for a while .. lol.

3 following 8 answers
anonymous
2008-12-04 18:44:45 UTC
Mitch and MSAD have the sensible and correct answers



But this reminds me of one of those ‘classic’ insurance claims that does the email rounds every year or so



"I started to turn and it was at this point I noticed a camel and an elephant tethered at the verge. This distraction caused me to lose concentration and hit a tree."



&



"In an attempt to kill a fly, I drove into a telephone pole."



Now since they were caused by an animal, but involved a tree etc, under proximate cause are they ‘collision’ or ‘other than collision‘?









Oh and my own favourite involving trees is always



“Coming home I drove into the wrong house and collided with a tree I don't have."



Happy Friday
Anonymous
2008-12-04 20:23:26 UTC
On the STANDARD PAP, in most states, hitting a deer is "other than collision". The way the policy is worded, though, is that if the person does not have "other than collision" coverage, in some states, they can collect under the collision coverage, for contact with an animal.



But that little caveat varies on a state by state basis.
?
2016-10-15 07:11:38 UTC
Hitting a deer or the rest that broken your vehicle (and being your fault) could be lined on the collision portion of a coverage. Taking the $,one thousand deductible could make the top rate decrease yet not by potential of very plenty. Your agent is right in advising against it.
anonymous
2014-08-13 20:27:35 UTC
You can get quotes in just a few minutes at - SALESQUOTES.INFO-



RE Car Insurance question: Hitting a deer is 'collision' .. hitting a tree is 'other than collision'?



So, on a Personal Auto Policy (PAP) if you hit a tree it's considered a 'Collision.' .. but if you hit a deer, it's considered 'Other Than Collision.'



... WHY?



Is it because trees don't move and deers do?
Boots
2008-12-04 18:29:51 UTC
You have it backwards.



Hitting the tree is collision.



Hitting the deer is other than collision.



A tree is a fixed object. When you hit a fixed object (tree,building, sign, pothole) it is a collision loss. Hitting other vehicles is also a collision loss. Think of it this way- you "collide" with something.



A deer is an animal. Other than collision (comprehensive) covers hitting animals (deer, dogs, skunk, bears etc). Most policies specifically list hitting an animal as an Other than Collision loss. Other than Collision covers those things that are not colliding with something. (fire, glass breakage, flood, theft).



The main difference: deer jump.....trees don't.



So....what happens if a deer runs out -you swerve, hit the deer and then go off road and hit a tree? This usually gets handled under Other than Collision since you hit the deer.





EDIT: Since you are taking a test -- here's a couple of things that I see trip folks up when they are learning about auto and homeowners policies.



When you are dealing with auto and homeowners - 1 thing that trips people up is Medical Payments coverage.



This coverage have a very big difference in the auto and homeowners version.



Automobile Med Pay- pays for medical bills (not wages/pain/suffering) incurred as a result of an accident for occupants in your vehicle regardless of fault (here's the different party) - it WILL pay for named insureds and residents of your household, as well as people who do not live in your household.



So- you and your friend are in a car - get hit. You both get a claim for medical payments coverage up to the per person policy limit.



Homeowners Med Pay- pays for medical bills (not wages/pain/suffering) incurred as a result of injuries that happen on the residence premises (insured property) regardless of fault. However, it does NOT pay for people who live there. It only covers people who do not live in your household.



So - you and your friend are standing on the deck of your home and the rail gives way and you both fall. Since your friend does not live in your house hold -she will have a claim under Medical Payments (and probably liability coverage too). However, since you live in the insured house - you will not have a claim for Medical Payments coverage. You are S.O.L.



I've even had attorneys screw this one up- so I wanted to point it out to you. Its a major difference that will help you understand the coverages better.





Also - another question people mess up-- is determining what is covered under an auto policy. A lot of people think that personal property is covered when it's in the car. Not true. The auto policy specifically excludes personal property.



So- how do you tell whats covered under the auto policy and whats covered under the home owners? Here's a simple rule of thumb that applies most of the time. If you were to take the car and turn it upside down and shake it....if it falls out it is not covered by the auto policy.



So- the Cd's in your car--will fall out. That is not covered under the auto policy. The CD player that is installed in the dash - will not fall out - it's covered under the auto policy.



The cell phones that are mounted into the car - will not fall out. They are now a permanent fixture in the car. Auto policy may cover. Cell phone that is just plugged into the cigarette lighter - will fall out - it is not covered under the auto policy.



In order for personal property to be covered when it is damaged/stolen from a car - you have to file under your homeowners policy.





Learning all this stuff at one time can be really tough. Hope this helps to clear up some of the issues for you.



Good luck on your test.
?
2017-03-09 20:41:19 UTC
I suggest you to try this site where you can compare quotes from different companies: http://cheapinsurancequotes1.info/index.html?src=5YAxnu68umH27deW1



RE :Car Insurance question: Hitting a deer is 'collision' .. hitting a tree is 'other than collision'?

So, on a Personal Auto Policy (PAP) if you hit a tree it's considered a 'Collision.' .. but if you hit a deer, it's considered 'Other Than Collision.'



... WHY?



Is it because trees don't move and deers do?

Update: MSAD - you are very observant! =]

I did word it wrong in the actual question, but I wrote it properly in the 'extended' part of the question.



'Collision' -- hitting a tree.

'Other than Collision' -- hitting a deer.



I understand the difference between the two, I just worded it wrong on the top part of the question.

I was just curious as to why one is 'other than collision' when you colided with an object in both cases =]

Thank you for clearing that up.



I am going to take a State Exam here pretty quick and I have a few random questions I'm still not piecing together.



Home Owners Insurance is driving me up the wall! lol.

All the policies and coverages .. property coverages .. not to mention I'm just now getting to the 'Business Auto' policies and 'Commercial Auto' policies .. on top of all the other forms I've already learned.



I'll probably be in this Insurance section for a while .. lol.

3 following 11 answers
?
2014-12-30 03:23:44 UTC
Get insurance quotes
anonymous
2016-08-30 07:47:03 UTC
Always when i post a question, even if it is the easiest one, they can't give me a good informed answer on this website. Wtf happened to people that actually make the effort to answer..
?
2015-12-15 23:38:50 UTC
Try https://tr.im/FBlxc


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...